Book Review: The Business of Baby
Posted by in BooksDid you ever feel as though maybe your doctor, your child’s doctor, and the companies that sell you products for your child don’t always have your best interests at heart? I think we’ve all had at least twinges of these feelings from time to time, and if you’ve had a bad experience with a doctor or hospital, you might feel very strongly about this.
Jennifer Margulis sees a pattern in all of this, and she wrote a book called The Business of Baby to investigate exactly what’s going on. (Disclosure: I did the index for this book, which allowed me to read it very carefully and is how the manuscript came into my hands. Please note I was not asked to write a review nor was it a condition of my creating the index. I don’t think Jennifer even knows I am writing a review). The book offers some very shocking facts.
Did you know it makes more financial sense for your doctor to do a C-section than to help you deliver vaginally?
Can you believe that the U.S. has one of the highest maternal mortality rates in developed countries?
Would you have imagined the U.S. has higher infant mortality rates than Scandinavian countries?
And did you know that the baby wash used in most hospitals has a laundry list of chemicals in it, including formaldehyde?
Ever wonder what happens to your baby’s foreskin after a circumcision? You probably didn’t know it’s often sold (for profit!) and used in beauty products and other surgeries.
Your prenatal vitamins? Full of chemicals.
Did you know medical students are taught to treat birth as an illness, not a natural process?
Did you know that many experts believe vaccinating a baby before one year of age is not only pointless, but dangerous, and that the infant’s immune system is not developed enough to actually make use of the vaccine? The list goes on and on.
Margulis did extensive investigative reporting for this book and even traveled to Scandinavia to find out why they do birth better. Her revelations are eye-opening. She displays a health care system that focuses only on profit. She shows us how far our birth and baby health care system has gone awry – pushing women and children into situations that are unhealthy for them while financially benefiting doctors, hospitals, and corporations. Her complex web of interviews with doctors, midwives, nurses, parents, and researchers paints a fairly grim picture of the options available to women and families in the U.S.
Margulis is out to make her point in this book – that point being that pregnancy, birth and infant care are overmedicalized, endangering women and children. If we took a step back and allowed the process to be less medical and more natural, she believes we would have better outcomes and healthier moms and babies. She does not lay out the opposing argument for you, so this is not a balanced take on the topic, but instead is one written from a very passionate viewpoint.
That being said, no matter what your feelings are about this topic, this is a very important book to read. You’ll be shocked, you’ll be angered, and you’ll start to think about how the system may have manipulated you without you even knowing. Even if you question Margulis’s conclusions, the evidence she presents will make you think and begin to wonder if your best interests have been pushed to the side in the race to make more and more money.
And maybe all of this will make you think about what the alternatives should be. Margulis is a proponent of midwives, homebirth, and breastfeeding, and suggests we need to reduce ultrasounds in pregnancies, change the vaccination schedule, and rethink what well baby care ought to be. Some of her views might shock you, but others might hit home. This book is going to start a national conversation about our preconceived notions about pregnancy, birth, and baby care. You want to read it so that you can form your own opinions.
You can follow any comment to this entry through the RSS 2.0 Both comments and pings are currently closed.
Sounds like an amazing book. I’m going to get a copy for my daughter.
My daughter is a pre-med student who spends one day a week shadowing an ob/gyn. I am buying a copy for her to read.
I’ve long suspected the C-Section thing, especially when my great niece, who had no complications during pregnancy and wasn’t otherwise high risk, was encouraged to have one.
I feel I was rushed into one as well and then my second one was just scheduled (I have big babies (11+ pounds), but I do wish I had had the chance to at least try)
Excellent post, Brette.
I’ve always been suspicious of the C-section levels, then a friend of mine a Latina lady of generous curves, was told her hips were too small to deliver. Yeah, right.
Yeah. When you’re in labor and scared, you will agree to almost anything if you’re told it will ensure your baby will be born safe and healthy. I have to say this book made me feel really terrible in some ways – decisions I made that in hindsight were wrong.
Wish I had this book when…
Yeah, that’s about the size of it.
I recently read an ARC of this book and found it incredibly eye opening.
I could have used this book back when there were no alternatives (that I knew of, anyway) but to give birth the “conventional” way. I’ll bet this changes a lot of viewpoints.
I’m buying the book, too, for my daughter and younger friends. Thanks for alerting us.
It’s true that when you’re in labor you’re so vulnerable. My easiest labor by far was my last–not even a Tylenol for pain. But by my third child I had a better idea of what to expect; I also had a midwife. She was excellent and encouraged me to take my time in labor and listen to my body.
I’m buying the book for my daughter as well as to read a book that’s been thoroughly researched and fact checked.
This is definitely a book that is going to create a lot of discussion!